Written by Kate Bullen, APD
Has anyone else noticed the expanding shelf space dedicated to kids focused yogurts in the supermarket? I have noticed for some time now, but have ignored them up until today (and thankfully my 4yo daughter hasn’t noticed the princess branded yogurts or she would have been demanding them much sooner!). I had assumed these are targeted at school lunchboxes and this hunch was confirmed on closer inspection with many of them saying ‘freeze for lunch boxes’.
So in the interest of research and providing information to our readers I succumbed and bought a selection of these yogurts and compared them to the more traditional types of yogurt.
| Mundella Premium Natural Yoghurt 500g | Yoplait Creamy Lite French Cheesecake yogurt 1kg | Vaalia kids strawberry yoghurt 140g | Nestle Strawberry yoghurt 70g | Yoplait Smackers Strawberry shine 8 x70g |
Cost | $3.98 ($0.80/100g) | $4.19 ($0.42/100g) | $1.89 ($1.35/100g) | $1.39 ($1.99/100g) | $4.99 ($0.89/100g) |
Energy/100g | 419kj | 396kj | 374kj | 373kj | 357kj |
Protein/100g | 4.6g | 4.5g | 4.6g | 3.6g | 3.3g |
Fat total/100g | 4.1g | 1.0g | 2.6g | 1.9g | 1.8g |
Fat saturated/100g | 2.9g | 0.6g | 1.6g | 1.2g | 1.2g |
Carbohydrate sugars/100g | 6.5g | 16.6g | 11.7g | 14.3g | 12.1g |
Sodium/100g | 60mg | 58mg | 74mg | 35mg | 45mg |
Calcium/100g | 200mg | 142mg | 155mg | 118mg | 200mg |
So what does this comparison tell us? You will notice that I have compared cost – for me this is highly relevant, as you can see the price per 100g varies considerably with the Nestle strawberry pouch pack (70g) costing nearly 5 times as much per 100g compared to the 1kg Yoplait tub. This can make a big difference on the weekly budget. I was quite pleased to see that the Yoplait smackers box of 8x70g squeezy tubes was only double the price of the 1kg tub – making it more affordable. Obviously with the smaller serves the consumer is paying for the convenience, the packaging and the marketing.
The first 2 columns of the above table compare the Mundella full fat premium 500g and Yoplait creamy lite 1kg tub yoghurts. These probably aren’t really targeted at the school lunchbox (unless you decant into a smaller container) – but I wanted to include them for a couple of reasons – the mundella natural yoghurt provides nothing but yoghurt. You will notice that the sugar content is very low at 6.5g/100g. I often buy this yoghurt for my 15 month old son and will either give it to him plain, or add my own fruit, as shown below. Full fat dairy products are recommended for children under the age of 2 to meet their high energy requirements.
If you have any concerns about additives or preservatives then Mundella is the yoghurt for you. As an added bonus it is made locally here in WA so you are supporting local and being more environmentally friendly by saving on air miles and using less disposable packaging.
I will often buy the 1kg lite yoghurt (whichever brand happens to be on special) as our family yoghurt. Great source of calcium, low in fat – but does have considerable sugar content.
Moving on to the final 3 columns in the table at the top – these are the squeezy tubes that are marketed directly at kids (you should have seen how excited my daughter was at the ‘princess’ yoghurt – oh my how powerful is advertising) and while I have chosen the pink varieties of yoghurt, there were just as many boy focused options. I find that my daughter responds really well when I set expectations up front. So, as I grabbed a few of these yoghurts at the supermarket today, and saw her eyes light up at the princess and pink packaging, I showed them to her and explained that these are just a special occasion yoghurt and I won’t be buying them all the time. I even went to the extent of telling her that they are still a healthy food but cost more because of the extra packaging. Information is power!

So what did I think of these squeezy tubes? In a nutshell I think they provide a great portable option for yoghurt. They are fantastic snack option that is low in fat and provides some wholesome nutrition. My biggest concerns would be the cost and the amount of packaging that is thrown away. But like with any convenience product, packaging plays a big part. My personal recommendation would be the Yoplait Smackers. Out of the 3 options that I reviewed they provided the best nutrition profile, and as an added bonus they worked out to be the most economical option with 8 x 70g tubes in a box.
I should point out that 2 of the products (Nestle strawberry and Yoplait Smackers) were 70g and the Vaalia kids was 140g per serve. So the smaller serves are good for younger kids (maybe 3-6yo) while the bigger serve would be more appropriate for older kids requiring more energy.
And finally, there are always the traditional 200g tubs that can be purchased in 6 or 8 packs – another good option for kids snacks – I haven’t reviewed them today, but they shouldn't be forgotten! These could also be frozen and popped into lunches. Or perfect for a quick snack when kids (or adults) get home. In terms of opening up the packs my 4yo daughter couldn’t open the squeezy tubes I reviewed today – but she has no trouble tearing the paper lid off the traditional 200g small tubs. Just another thing to consider!
So next time you are choosing yoghurts, here are a few more options and things to think about.